Cross-cultural teen book review: "Borderline" by Allan Stratton

70

By Giselle Maine

Islamic tiles.  Credit and copyright: Lize Rixt.  Used under license from stock photo site sxc.hu
Islamic tiles. Credit and copyright: Lize Rixt. Used under license from stock photo site sxc.hu

"Borderline" by Allan Stratton. First published 2010 by HarperTeen.

A fascinating and action-packed teen novel, "Borderline" by Allan Stratton is told from the point of view of Muslim-American teenage boy Sami Sabiri. Born in the USA to Iranian parents, Sami is a typical teen who is just trying to fit in. His parents value education and the Muslim religion, while Sami often finds some of their Islamic home culture not so easy to fit in with his all-American surroundings (such as trying to do his midday prayers at school). However, he seems to be doing an admirable job of respecting his Iranian cultural heritage while also dealing with everyday issues common to American teens.

At the start of this teen book, Sami's differences begin to make him a target for bullying at school. However, this problem pales by comparison when Sami suspects his father of lying about something to him and his mother. Can he really trust his father? Just when he is beginning to think everything could work out OK, his family's world gets turned upside down and it becomes evident that they have gotten into something really big, and not in a good way.

Is Sami's father really the loving, gentle yet firm man he seems to be? Or is there a more sinister side to him? Is it in Sami's power to save his father, and if so, would he want to do so? And what is his father's secret, anyway?

The pressures keep piling onto Sami throughout this action-packed book. Trying to walk the line of what he believes, caught between two very different ways of looking at things, Sami exemplifies the title of this book: "Borderline".

The author's research

It is evident both from reading this young adult novel and from the acknowledgments page that Allan Stratton has made every effort to research the US Muslim community and also the US (and international) laws relevant to the plot. This background information is expertly woven into the plot for the reader's benefit and makes the book an eye-opener.

One minor criticism is that the author has not made as much effort to research the details of the career of a scientist (Sami's father earns much more and dresses unusually well for work if he is supposed to be a public sector scientist, or else he works in an unusually secure facility for a private sector lab). However, this is not critical to the plot.

Allan Stratton included sources from the legal fields in both the US and Canada; a press attaché to an American embassy who had worked during a hostage crisis; and a national security reporter, to name just a few. This research imparts plenty of credibility to the plot of this captivating and original young adult book.

The bigger picture

Author Allan Stratton addresses a much bigger picture than simply what happens to Sami and his family. He deals with questions such as: What is the effect on someone's family when they are accused of a crime? And is it possible for bystanders to be ensnared by laws designed to protect citizens from terrorism? And finally, how do we perceive those with different religions or cultural backgrounds to our own?

Who will enjoy this book?

Teens of all ages will find "Borderline" to be a compelling and thought-provoking read while still enjoying all the fast paced action of this novel. In fact, many adults will find this book to be a gripping eye-opener too!

This teen novel will also resonate with those who relate to the theme of not-always-straightforward father-son relationships. Note that the absence of a strong female lead (or indeed, any major female character) other than Sami's mother may make some teen girls less likely to identify with this book. However, this is a minor point, because the cross-cultural angle and the thought-provoking ethical questions posed in this book ultimately create a memorable read for both genders.

Amazon shortcut to the book:

Borderline
A compelling read which really makes teens think about cross-cultural issues.
Amazon Price: $4.95
List Price: $16.99

Conclusion

This fast-paced teen book has universal appeal for young adult readers. It makes teens really think about cross-cultural issues and difficult ethical questions while still delivering a page-turning plot they will enjoy.

If you enjoy books, you'll also like...

  • Book review - Futuristic teen novel "Matched" by Ally Condie

    "Matched" by Ally Condie is a teen novel describing a futuristic world where officials decide your life for you - and everyone seems happy about it. When 17 year old Cassia starts questioning these pre-made choices, a lot happens. - 3 months ago

  • Cross-cultural teen book review: "Borderline" by Allan Stratton

    The cross-cultural teen book "Borderline" by Allan Stratton is told from the point of view of a Muslim-American teen boy. This young adult novel makes teens think about difficult ethical questions while still delivering a page-turning plot. - 10 months ago

  • Teen Book Review for Both Genders: "Bruiser" by Neal Shusterman

    "Bruiser" by Neal Shusterman is about secrets, family and friendship. This teen novel challenges the reader to think about questions such as: How far would you go for a family member? For a friend? This is a gripping action-packed book for young adults. - 12 months ago

  • Three Best Magazines for Intellectual Women

    Several magazines recommended for the intellectual woman are described in this article. Pros and cons of each magazine are also listed. - 21 months ago

Comments

Phil Plasma profile image

Phil Plasma 10 months ago

Thanks for sharing this - I will add it to my hub-recommended book list.

Giselle Maine profile image

Giselle Maine Hub Author 10 months ago

Hi Phil, glad you're interested in the book. Yes I found this book to be a memorable read with a message that stays around long after the book is finished.

vijayanths 9 months ago

useful information, thanks for sharing it.

Giselle Maine profile image

Giselle Maine Hub Author 9 months ago

Hi Vijayanths, thanks for stopping by and commenting. Yes, this book covered important and difficult issues, and in my opinion the author did a superb job of using fiction very effectively to make the reader think about the laws of today.

anusha15 profile image

anusha15 Level 3 Commenter 8 months ago

You continue to amaze me with your innovative writing style, Giselle. It was a great hub - I generally don't write monotonous book reviews - I find them intriguing when they contain the reviewer's opinion. And you state your opinion with a lot of conviction, it was very interesting read.

I loved the way you've used the right side capsule for Author's research and I really admire the information/views you've put in there. This is a kind of review which would be constructive for the author himself.

Giselle Maine profile image

Giselle Maine Hub Author 8 months ago

Hi Anusha, I'm glad you liked the review and the layout - your positive words mean a lot to me.

The bit about the author's research was something I really wanted to include because I could see just by reading the book that the author had really done lots of research. The only thing that really jarred with me was the research science career, but that is mainly because I have a science background myself - otherwise I doubt I would have noticed the (ultimately minor) issues with that - like I said, it didn't affect the main plot.

Thanks for stopping by, it is great to hear from you. I am amazed at how you always manage to come up with fresh new ideas like the one in your other comment about Webanswers.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working